Dead Men Walking

Old Server Admin Section => SOG War Room => Silver Oak Guardians => Archived Topics => SOG Archive => Topic started by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 08:18:05 AM

Title: Huhuran
Post by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 08:18:05 AM
Trying to pull together all of my thoughts from last night to make some sense for the strategy next week.

The Good
Pallies and all other healers wearing full NR gear and not being part of the meat shield.

The Bad
The aggro management.
Huhuran moving around and therefore changing the 15 closest people.

We have *got* to solve these last two.

I like the Righteous answer to the question 'who do you use as your meatshield': their answer was 6 tanks, 5 rogues and 4 hunters.  The answer is telling because it was not 'the highest 20', or the 'top 15 NR', it was specific.  So they probably have everyone else in normal gear.  Maybe we need to tell people in other positions ( ie those in the non-meatshield) to wear normal gear?

Did healers have to spend much time keeping Hunters alive?  I forgot to check my meters before the raid finished - damn I wish SWstats stored info and didn;t lose it as soon as someone leaves the raid.  The hunters have generally low NR (sub-200 except Nebuoh with 284) but are part of the meat shield.  Should they have more - I would say yes - they should all be aiming for over 250 and closer to 300 if they are meatshield material.

Tanks NR is excellent (all 294 or higher) but why are we losing some so early?  Do we need to change healer strategy to cope?

Rogues NR is good for the most part, but we have a few weaker ones who need a kick to get their NR up.  Bastet - can you spread the word?

If we get Tanks, Hunters and Rogues NR up then we have an excellent meatshield to heal.
If we have a good meatshield then we should be able to have more people in normal gear and able to heal or DPS better.

And how do we control aggro?

Discuss......

TL.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Bastet on October 04, 2006, 08:42:16 AM
not sure why this was in the druid thread, but split off.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 08:51:40 AM
I was looking for that - bloody wierd it ended up there!  Thanks Bastet, I thoguth I was going mad having posted and then being unable to find it!

TL.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Padding on October 04, 2006, 09:01:00 AM
Just talked to some more people, and it seems that they are givining out pots to all people, not only the first 15.... yes more expensive but maybe an idea?
Title: Huhuran
Post by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 09:08:31 AM
Damn, I'm sure I just posted a reply to this but I cannot find it.

I'll try to get mats for multiple pots for the next run - we'll need some help gathering Elemental Earth & Dreamfoil though.  I'll edit the GMOTD as soon as the server is back up.  Expensive it might be, but I want Huhu down regularly so we can work on Twins - and we can cope with the expense at the moment given that the +4 just sold for 2k :biggrin:

TL.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Padding on October 04, 2006, 09:10:17 AM
Yeah i agree fully
 
I still also have around 17K on SOGBANK.... The market for Dark Iron Armor is fairly saturated though, so i wont be creating anymore for sale at the moment. Maybe in a few weeks time or so
Title: Huhuran
Post by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 09:20:38 AM
Did anyone see if anyone cured the Wyvern Stong (causing the 4k damage to MTs)?  I'm just trying to think of why they went down so very quick.

TL.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Padding on October 04, 2006, 09:23:51 AM
On the last try? No, but Vargen talked about last tranq shot might've missed
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Bastet on October 04, 2006, 10:15:51 AM
Only a failed tranq can cause that much dmg in that limited a time frame, ppl dont cleanse so it cant be that.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: TeaLeaf on October 04, 2006, 11:48:29 AM
So what is hitting tanks so hard?  Ragnarh can you provide more info?

TL.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Vargen on October 04, 2006, 12:10:34 PM
The last try I can only explain by a tranq not hitting or not being fired. 3 tanks don't die in 3 seconds when they all had 100% health to start with. So we can rule that out as bad luck.
 
As for the hunters replacing the paladins in the meatshield group I think is a step in the right direction. They just need to work on thei NR so we don't loose tranqshot midfight.
 
I really don't see a reason to give NR pots to everyone though. I only really take any damage at all when she goes past 30% and ppl start to die. Other then that it could be that some get damage due to the silecning poinson, but that isn't such a biggie.
 
I think what hurt us the most was that Threb and Whisperer weren't there, as they both easily outheal the newer druids atm. The paladins helped that issue, but you really need a few goes to get into who needs healing, and they were kind of thrown into it. The one that has aggro will need most of the healing, and then the one that takes over aggro. But you still need to slap a few heals on the first tank as he will still get damage from the debuffs. Maybe it would be enough warning for the healers if we called on TS when the other tank is taking over and who is taking over. Giving some extra seconds to think in a fight like this helps.
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Padding on October 04, 2006, 12:12:11 PM
QuoteAs for the hunters replacing the paladins in the meatshield group I think is a step in the right direction. They just need to work on thei NR so we don't loose tranqshot midfight

I agree.... TL can you perhaps cook up a wording for the hunters so they know that they should be around 280-300NR before sunday
Title: Huhuran
Post by: Vargen on October 04, 2006, 09:17:54 PM
How about you tell them that if they aren't by next raid I will scream at them? :norty: