Dead Men Walking

dMw Chit Chat => The Beer Bar => It's my Birthday! => Topic started by: Michelanio on October 28, 2010, 10:25:27 PM

Title: Would you do it?
Post by: Michelanio on October 28, 2010, 10:25:27 PM
Nasa have plans to send 4 people to Mars and even though that sounds fantastic, there is one small catch, you can't return home...

Full article here (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1324192/Nasa-plan-Hundred-Year-Starship--mission-astronauts-Mars-leave-forever.html)

But the question remains, would you do it?
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: T-Bag on October 28, 2010, 11:23:46 PM
The original moon landings were made with the expectation that the return trip was unlikely...though unlike this they'd actually planned one. The tough bit about space travel is fuel. It takes a lot of fuel to break orbit, when you're on Earth you need huge rockets, on the moon it's easier, but still not easy. That's why it's so hard to get back. Imagine a lunar lander type ship launching from Earth, it's just not possible, so it's a big job to do the return trip, but certainly worth the outward trip anyway.

I'm sure they'll have people jumping at the chance. Fully trained astronauts will be fighting for the chance to be picked...but that's just it, these are going to be fully trained astronauts, and judging by the 2030 ETA and allowing for some delays etc the peopl that will go are probably not even born yet. Lovely idea, but I wouldn't hold my breath for my chance to go...but given the chance I can't see why I wouldn't go, it's the chance of a lifetime...only problem is the ping issues.
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: Blunt on October 29, 2010, 12:08:08 AM
Quote from: Michelanio;318556Nasa have plans to send 4 people to Mars and even though that sounds fantastic, there is one small catch, you can't return home...

Full article here (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1324192/Nasa-plan-Hundred-Year-Starship--mission-astronauts-Mars-leave-forever.html)

But the question remains, would you do it?
Depends who the other 3 are:norty:
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: DuVeL on October 29, 2010, 12:13:13 AM
Quote from: Blunt;318558Depends who the other 3 are:norty:

It depends, how is the internetconnection up there?
I'll bring some waffles, are you bringing the beers Pete?
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: Benny on October 29, 2010, 07:39:53 AM
I was going to post something deep and meaningful and then link a picture from the google search for 'sexy astronauts'....then I saw the results. It's a no from me. (if you have safe search off I suggest you be careful)
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: Penfold on October 29, 2010, 08:12:13 AM
lol Benny.

No, not for me but I know I few people I'd like to volunteer for a one way trip to Mars :)
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: delanvital on October 29, 2010, 10:54:24 AM
Quote from: T-Bag;318557The original moon landings were made with the expectation that the return trip was unlikely...though unlike this they'd actually planned one.

That is a bit simply put - the trip was a planned return trip with the intention of bringing them home. The lander and other modules were tested as much as possible on earth, however seriously inadequate. They were, however, fully aware of the risks and, at the time equivocal, variables involved.

What a wonderful question. I have had a dream of going since seeing the pics from the Vikings as a kid

[ATTACH=CONFIG]592[/ATTACH]

I really don't know what to answer. In the end, on the ramp, would I go... I don't know.
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: Gorion on October 29, 2010, 04:27:47 PM
I would, as long as they supply cyanide pills just in case.

Wouldn't want to die suffocating that's for sure.  I would also need a supercomputer, a dedicated satellite and unlimited game/net access.

And let's not forget feminine "company", has to be good looking and preferably with pale white skin.
Title: Would you do it?
Post by: smilodon on October 29, 2010, 05:07:47 PM
I read the article and noticed that nowhere was Pete Wardren quoted as saying the mission would be a one way trip. That quote was attributed to two independent scientists who have nothing much to do with Nasa. I'm quite willing to believe the Hundred Years Starship is fully intending to bring it's Astronauts home. There's a big difference between an Astronaut and a colonist. Remember the link is to a Daily Mail website folks. They have never let an inconvenient fact get in the way of a good story. :)

That being said I'd quite fancy being first down the ramp. It's a sort of immortality :)