I just aquired this from a certain peer-2-peer network, and its a dissapointment :(
Graphics: Awful, they look 5 years old
Gameplay: Steep learning curve due to the controls, set plays are bloody hard to get right, but once you get the hang of passing down your line, you can give the ball to Robinson and score a try 99% of the time. Kicking drop goals however is incredibly satisfying :)
Sound: I dont know about everyone else, but my sound keeps cutting out and the crowd dont respond to the game at all. Commentry is rubbish compared to the new FIFA games. Menu music is ok <_<
Overall I'd give it 5/10, just on the basis that its rugby, and england can win things :D