Gilmarion

[Padding]

http://www.deadmen.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?t=15421
 
We need to make a decision on this one, unless you already discussed it
 
Personally i dont have a problem with it, but i want to make sure he doesnt promote Righteous too much if he comes in here again

[TeaLeaf]

Do we not have a rule about not having an alt in Guild if your main is not here?

TL.

[Padding]

Where does it say that?

[TeaLeaf]

In everything we do - we never admit alts unless main is full member.  It's current Guild practice.  Admitting Gil when he was retiring his main was one thing as Gil would have been the main, but accepting Gil when a main is elsewhere is something we have regularly denie din the past for other members.  It is therefore fair to treat them the same way n'est ce pas?

TL.

[Padding]

Ok, lets tell him that. Its a no brainer, and a no go.

[TeaLeaf]

I asked a question, I'm just awaiting responses.  If we say yes do we have a problem, do we set a precendent.  Is it something we are happy to 'overlook', what message might this send other members seeing as we already lost several to Righteous.  What happens if someone joins Danu and wants their alt in SoG still, do we let them and is that an increased risk to lose others?  These are the types of question I am posing and would like considered before doing anything with the Gil application, but I am in agreement that we need to do it quickly, ideally today.

TL.

[Bastet]

theres some more applicants on the tabble, and i think it would be wise to meet up a half hour before the raid and talk all of em over, lets fill our class devicancy (sp) asap.

[Padding]

I'll try to be on early to have a talk about all the things i've promised