Main Menu

Frustartion in rgw

Started by JonnyAppleSeed, June 14, 2011, 10:47:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

JonnyAppleSeed

pm fom lego

Quote                PM as promised             

                                                                                                                              The disturbing points about Dreaman:

- benching some people more than others (unfair shares) (I'm in luck as  ranged dps to never be benched, that's unfair too towards melee mostly)
- being negative, mostly about the dps amount, but also about other  things ('poor performance'), though never about the healing...
- his behaviour tends towards the behaviour of a bully: picking on the one you think is the weakest link.
- saying "someone (you know who you are) did something wrong", in raid  chat, but not helping to improve. Experience learns that it simply does  not work this way, the person you mean never feels addressed.
- Also heard the term arrogant from another player, think he is just very sure of himself.
- Somehow he is frustrated, by lack of progressing or players not as good as he thinks he is.

Last raid (13-06), things I think just not done:
- bringing an alt of a DMR player not in RGW when a RGW member was benched (same role, dps, ranged in vs melee out)
- whispering *** to a team member, and then logging off without explanation of the whisper.

And just to clear things up:
- I'm in favor of fair shares for everyone
- I'm grateful for all the help we get from all other guildmembers to fill up roles we are short on, and help on tactics
- I don't envy Dreaman in his role, and I'm glad he is doing that work for us.

Just as I said on TS, you can tell that this is from me.                                   
                              
          


Who was the non guild alt brought in ?

Ill try catch drea pre raid and see if he wants to vent any concerns
It is by caffeine alone I set my mind in motion. It is by the beans of Java that thoughts acquire speed, the hands acquire shakes, the shakes become a warning. It is by caffeine alone I set my mind in motion


Whitey

Non guild alt would be TL's Shammy.

TeaLeaf

God give me strength. :frusty:

Here's my line by line interpretation of what he has to say:

Quote from: Lego- benching some people more than others (unfair shares) (I'm in luck as ranged dps to never be benched, that's unfair too towards melee mostly)
I have not seen this happen.  Looking at the attendance website we do not have the attendance levels to have queues and to create this problem.  Specifics please or the complaint has to be ignored.
Quote from: Lego- being negative, mostly about the dps amount, but also about other things ('poor performance'), though never about the healing...
A quick check of the logs shows why.  If RGW wants to progress there are some players who need to pick it up as it will hold the entire raid back.  Is that fair on those who commit their time & effort to be held back by people who clearly have not got a clue and have not put the effort into correcting their problems?

The healing in RGW is rarely the problem and where it is it tends to be screamingly obvious - because someone dies.  The softer performance issues are about dps, movement, control and that's where the biggest gains come from once people stop dying.  It is therefore inevitable that the focus is on dps/performance rather than making sure that an equal amount of blame is given to everyone irrespective of whether there is a problem or not.  That's raiding, that's common sense.  It's illogical to ignore it.
Quote from: Lego- his behaviour tends towards the behaviour of a bully: picking on the one you think is the weakest link.
- saying "someone (you know who you are) did something wrong", in raid chat, but not helping to improve. Experience learns that it simply does not work this way, the person you mean never feels addressed.
A RL has to be allowed to identify a problem with a specific player and we should be mature enough to deal with it.  Drea is never rude, or 'shouty' about it in my experience, but quite calm and level -headed.  There is not time in a raid to talk someone through their class rotation or to solve and fix why they always die to having the wrong buff on Council, you identify the problem and then get people to take individual responsibility.  This is RGW, not Kindergarten.
Quote from: Lego- Also heard the term arrogant from another player, think he is just very sure of himself.
Not sure where this comes from.  Drea tries to keep a good handle on the raid group, someone has to and he is the only one delivering that direction that they need.  If Lego thinks he is arrogant (and I have never heard anyone else say anything similar about Drea) then it is a problem that Lego has, not Drea.
Quote from: Lego- Somehow he is frustrated, by lack of progressing or players not as good as he thinks he is.
Given some of the repeated movement fails, repeated poor dps I can entirely understand why he is frustrated, frustrated by stupidity.
Quote from: LegoLast raid (13-06), things I think just not done:
- bringing an alt of a DMR player not in RGW when a RGW member was benched (same role, dps, ranged in vs melee out)
- whispering *** to a team member, and then logging off without explanation of the whisper.
No idea about the latter, but I believe the former was me on my shaman.

Without my healer the raid would have been cancelled.  Quite happy to see the RGW raid cancelled, but Drea figured that he'd rather run the raid with an alt than tell everyone to take an early bath, so I'm afraid this comment from him is complete rubbish.  And for the record, I swapped out for the missing healer when Lynx(?) eventually showed up several hours late.
Quote from: Lego- I'm grateful for all the help we get from all other guildmembers to fill up roles we are short on, and help on tactics
Apparently not so grateful if it is a non-guild alt healer that means the raid does not get cancelled.
Quote from: Lego- I don't envy Dreaman in his role, and I'm glad he is doing that work for us.
The only decent thing he has said so far.  Unfortunately he is supporting with one breath and then sending in his torpedoes with the next.

I'm sorry to be negative here, but as far as I can see there is almost nothing there for us to work with.  Almost everything he has complained about is either unjustified or reasonable given the nature of raiding.  

I think the problem might be more in Lego's view of how the world and the raid should be run.  Unfortunately, without a good & firm hand at the tiller RGW would not exist for Lego to moan about.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Whitey

You need to remember that Lego left RGT for similar reasons.  I don't think he likes the type of structured, analysed raiding needed for progression.

TeaLeaf

Yep, I said as much last night on TS and hopefully reiterated that in my above post.   I think the problem is Lego.

Sent using Tapatalk, fingers, thumbs and sticky tape.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

JonnyAppleSeed

Totaly agree ... I have no issue with drea and the way hes been running the raids can only be be given a thumbs up. Lego seems way over sensetive
It is by caffeine alone I set my mind in motion. It is by the beans of Java that thoughts acquire speed, the hands acquire shakes, the shakes become a warning. It is by caffeine alone I set my mind in motion