Main Menu

Gruul

Started by TeaLeaf, October 11, 2007, 10:50:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

TeaLeaf

The poll that is up has a fair few sign ups on it.  Why not give some impetus to both you as officers, the members and those who might join by setting a date for SOG's first raid night to Gruul?  It is almost irrelevant how it went, it is more about having been there.  It might cheer the troops and give them something to shoot for.  Worst case scenario is that it does nothing for morale, which in my opinion leaves you no worse off than now.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Gorion

not to sound negative, but theres 16 signups in total and 3-4 of those barely raid, plus the way kz has been going doesnt give me much hope
 
imo, we should wait a couple of weeks, 1st we have to talk to the healers that just joined, cos just soulcase has attended a raid, the rest are missing
 
we might also need a couple more tanks
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

TeaLeaf

I'm not saying you're ready right now, but setting a date gives you a deadline to work to and without a deadline then things tend to drift.....  :tumbleweed:

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

sheepy

I say middle of November should be set as a date.
[quote=smilodon;228785]
Sheepy appears and begins to stroke my head. According to his slurred drunken speech I am "lovely and like a fuzzy felt". Thankfully he soon leaves and passes out somewhere. [/quote]

Lucian

End of October for me...
AKA Bobbyus
 

TeaLeaf

#5
:tumbleweed:

See how easily things drift?

Anyway.  Here's some thoughts.

Currently:  
SOG online activity is almost non-existent at the moment.  (I am spending a load of time on my priest and hunter and often it is just me and one or two others online for most of the day.  This morning, Saturday, there were just 2 others online!)
Without activity you will lose more of your active people.......then the Guild will be an increasingly small group of friends who gradually see each other less and less.  The guild will ultimately atrophy to nothing if this continues.

You need more activity.

Proposal:
I had hoped that the Karazhan raids would ignite some passion and cause people to become more interested and active, but I now believe you need a more agressive approach.  Something along these lines:

  • Temporarily change the recruitment process to allow any officer to make an immediate and unilateral decision to invite someone as soon as an application is posted (if necessary even invite them and then tell them to join the forums).
  • Keep the post count up as has recently been done by putting new info about WoW onto the SOG forum every day.
  • Announce a date for Gruul.  The last 2 members to leave wanted to raid beyond Karazhan, but we had not told them when SOG were plannign to be there.  Announcing a date might make others stop and hold on a bit longer.
  • Get some lower level toons into the guild - the new players or the newer toons, they're the ones who are going to be active in the long term whilst levelling.  The current SOG population consists of mainly L70 mature characters where the online time is minimal.  Get fresh blood, if necesssary dust down your old L12 alt and go spend some time on it; get new members in at each alt level range.  Make it the Officers' job to get new members - even set  targets if you need to.  Do anything to get activity in guild chat up.
  • Add more officers.  An increasing number of the officers are now part-time, irregular or in almost permanent retirement.  I mean no offence to anyone by this comment, but it is a major problem for the guild when the leadership is hardly ever online.
I know that an open recruitment policy will potentially trigger some bad eggs joining, but then you can always kick the prats - and remembert it would be the officers who do the inviting so you have nobody to blame but yourself if you pick up the odd tit here and there!

Radical moves are called for I think to get SOG going again as it is in my opinion reaching an almost terminal level of inactivity.  

I know that 'the values of SOG' might ber diluted int he short term, but if you do nothing then SOG will die and die.  Get new members in quickly, teach them, coach them, mould them into 'fit & proper' SOG members - that's what Officers are for.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Lucian

I'm with TL.  I agree with all of the above. Fresh blood is definitely needed.
AKA Bobbyus
 

sheepy

im also in agreement i think we need some more ppl around
[quote=smilodon;228785]
Sheepy appears and begins to stroke my head. According to his slurred drunken speech I am "lovely and like a fuzzy felt". Thankfully he soon leaves and passes out somewhere. [/quote]

Gorion

my oppinion is,
 
1) inform the members of what we need to start gruuls, ie: class numbers, gear level and activity. once those criteria are met, we start the week after (we also say this in the same thread)
 
that should spark some interest in Kz even if some dont need anything from there
 
2) the low lvl inviting sounds ok, if the usual application rules are still done
 
3) instead of inviting blindly, which is out of the question. shorten the application duration Asap. (2 days public, 1 day officers should be enough. every officer should check the forums daily unless the rest of us are informed he is on break)
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

TeaLeaf

I think I'm suggesting something more radical than you have outlined Gorion.

You meet someone in a PUG, you like them, they play well, you invite.  In the current system this would nto happen and 3 days later the perosn would be guilded and the opportunity lost.  SOG od not have 3 days to wait.

I'm not advocating dropping all standards, what I am advocating is the devolution of powers from a committee to the officers.  If you trust your officer implicitly then they ought to be trusted to invite people directly into the guild.  Not as a permanent measure, but as a short term measure until you have numbers and more importantly activity back up again.

Re Gruul.  Saying "when we have the numbers" is not sufficient imo as it is effectively nothing more than what you have already said.  Take a risk, set a date.  Now you might miss it, but at leaat you had a go and people can start preparing for it.  Deadlines help things happen.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Gorion

its not a matter of trust, its a matter of someone might know bad things about somebody while every single officer cant know everything about everyone. its about reducing too much of our standards
 
the solution is shorter application processing, made a thread in the recruitment section
 
 
a failed deadline is a bad hit imo,  in the way i proposed it would make the deadline totally dependant on the members, if they want to raid gruul they need to join raids.
 
we also might need to limit how much "social raiding guild" are we going into, we still have the raiding part attached and if most of the members decide to not join any raids (like these couple of weeks), then we need to consider some rule changing and rotten branch cutting - making a different thread for this
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB