The Final solution

Started by Sazgul, July 26, 2006, 11:10:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Siffredi

Well i have read it, and i still think it does not benefit those putting heart and soul into raidgroup. This gives all even those with poor attendence equal easieness to get into those raids they want to. However i can see that its hard to find a easy non follow up signup system. Any other system would give the Marshals and RL some adminstation. A very important thing is that we have to change the keyword every time and sometimes make it a complete odd one, so noone can possible make macros and such for it.
This may be the easiest and best solution at this time. We may possibly loose some that dont get into raid (speaking of the case with Keltor last time), but we just have to live with that. The entire raid does not depend on one person and all can be replaced, so i think we should go puplic with this and make clear that this is the system for all future raids with no exeptions. This also means that we cannot prioritise anyone. Anyone knows if its possible to auto set in /rakw to stop when 5 have been invited?
Siffredi - 60 human warrior
Zentobar - 60 NE rogue
Sirzoidac - 60 human paladin
Sanhomadun- 60 human priest
Nibsen - 60 gnome mage
Digales - 43 gnome warlock
Siffer - 36 NE druid

Sazgul

Quote from: SiffrediWell i have read it, and i still think it does not benefit those putting heart and soul into raidgroup. This gives all even those with poor attendence equal easieness to get into those raids they want to. However i can see that its hard to find a easy non follow up signup system. Any other system would give the Marshals and RL some adminstation. A very important thing is that we have to change the keyword every time and sometimes make it a complete odd one, so noone can possible make macros and such for it.
This may be the easiest and best solution at this time. We may possibly loose some that dont get into raid (speaking of the case with Keltor last time), but we just have to live with that. The entire raid does not depend on one person and all can be replaced, so i think we should go puplic with this and make clear that this is the system for all future raids with no exeptions. This also means that we cannot prioritise anyone. Anyone knows if its possible to auto set in /rakw to stop when 5 have been invited?

As for the last part, i dont know if /rakw can invite only 5, I dont think so.
 
And this IS the best system for now.. And if people know this, there's no excuse for beeing mad over not comming along... I think we wont see a problem of the same scale again (thinking our first BWL) - At least not untill our first AQ40 / Naxx :P
 
Well all agree - Last one to spam here is OA, does anyone mind any spelling?

DarkAngel

Been thinking about this and i must admit coming down to LIFO is quite harsh, as its about who can ask for invite first. So in regards to this i am still not sure this is the right way but being that we need to come to a agreement i guess at this moment at time it will have to do.
 
But i must admit keeping it simple while be far easier to control, but this system is still far from fair.


Bastet

well, its the only system that gives every1 a fighting chance to get in, we talked about a lot of systems, but most would make the gap between the in bwl crowd, and out bwl crowd bigger and bigger, and making the out crowd more and more unlikely to ever join.
 
This system might not yield the best group, but thats something that will happen from time to time. You can adapt and rise to the occasion :smile:
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Nefrion

With the LIFO system we also avoid people starting to blame officers/marshalls that they might prefer some from others.
 
The more complex a system you choose the more people will eventually complain and question it's fairness. I think we have to take this into consideration as well.
 
 
br
60 Rogue Nefrion| Class Leader | Defender |
60 Paladin Delle| Alt |
61 Warrior Arc| Alt |

Sazgul

I will announce this in the appropriate forum when I take my lunchbreak.
 
So you have 50 min. to disagree :taz: :biggrin: