Main Menu

030806 Mc

Started by Nefrion, August 04, 2006, 06:56:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Nefrion

/signed Greatdanes.


Just have to add that threats from other players will not lead to that the marshalls will take action on a player.

I do agree that we should show RG2 that we do take this job seriously and so should they!
60 Rogue Nefrion| Class Leader | Defender |
60 Paladin Delle| Alt |
61 Warrior Arc| Alt |

Sazgul

Great lets have a chat with.
 
I would love to do it. - Would like to have you guys post here what I should discuss with him.
 
Something like
A. this and this
B. this and that.
 
Or shall I just do it in a general way. Telling him that we have some issues he needs to work on?
 
The faster the better.

Greatdanes

agree Nefrion - threats from others players should not have effect on our job, but this guy have being a problem for so long now and we will still not take action.
 
But if I remember correct the guy have not even being giving a warning yet!
 
I think it is time to give him a warning and if he continue bitching and whine over everything, a week or 2 in the penalty box is in place.
¤ GD ¤
 
Greatdanes LVL 70 Dwarf Hunter # Professions : Leatherworker
Megabyte LVL 60 Human Paladin # Professions : Mining + Herballism
Ushar LVL 60 Dwarf Priest # Professions : Tailoring + Enchanting
Minimand LVL 60 Gnome Mage # Professions : Alchemy + Engineering
Cæsar LVL 51 Human Rogue # Professions : Herballism + Alchemy
+ some low lvl

Sazgul

We cant do any sanctions GD - We can have a chat with him, letting him know what is not acceptable. Then we can see if he improves, if not we might wanna reevaluate his Defender status. But at least he has to be made aware of what we dislike / will not tolerate, then he has something to keep too, and he will have been given a chance to improve.

Mazii

Quote from: SazgulWe cant do any sanctions GD - We can have a chat with him, letting him know what is not acceptable. Then we can see if he improves, if not we might wanna reevaluate his Defender status. But at least he has to be made aware of what we dislike / will not tolerate, then he has something to keep too, and he will have been given a chance to improve.

I agree. And to the ultimatum Buford have given us, we cant do anything about.

Greatdanes

Why can't we give sanctions? We do have a penalty box i the guild, what's that for/to then?
 
Ofc he has to be aware we dislike / will not tolerate his behaviour, but have we done that yet, not as I remember it....even this has being going on for months now.
 
QuoteOriginally Posted by Mazii
I don't know anything about the issue, Sazgul. I handed out buffs last night as allways, and I think everybody buffed what they should - and noone was bitching as far as I saw!? Who told you?
I am really surprice by this Mazii - because I know Buford did contact you after the raid last time.
¤ GD ¤
 
Greatdanes LVL 70 Dwarf Hunter # Professions : Leatherworker
Megabyte LVL 60 Human Paladin # Professions : Mining + Herballism
Ushar LVL 60 Dwarf Priest # Professions : Tailoring + Enchanting
Minimand LVL 60 Gnome Mage # Professions : Alchemy + Engineering
Cæsar LVL 51 Human Rogue # Professions : Herballism + Alchemy
+ some low lvl

Nefrion

Lets have a chat with him then, shall we?

First we need to find out what the main problem is with this dude. Have a chat with Buford who seems to be one of the affected in this matter. Next I think we should do as Saz proposed with a list of issues we need to discuss with him... And probably also a list of improvements? With that list in mind we can easily measure if he has improved in the way we mentioned... And if not he will be demoted to soldier.

my 2 cents
60 Rogue Nefrion| Class Leader | Defender |
60 Paladin Delle| Alt |
61 Warrior Arc| Alt |

Sazgul

QuotePS. - I have being inform by Buford if there will be no action from the Marshall again, he will resign from SoG and stop playing because he think's we are incompetent in our jobs and he is sick and tried of no action taken.
I will be really sad if this happen but it's seems to be so if I understand the reply's correct and that will force me to re-evaluate my job as Marshall.
[/I]
 
I didnt quite get the last part. But we are taking action, we cant just jump out and kick people all of a sudden. They have to be warned, and next time Richardi is online i'll have a chat with him. Then Id like EVERYONE to monitor his behavior, if its not improving at BWL tomorrow, we have to put stronger measures in work.
 
Do we agree on that I'll have a chat with him?

Greatdanes

The first reply's on Richardi behaviour in this thread was ones again, let's us wait and see what the future will brings...
 
Totally agree Sazgul - a chat with the guy will be a good start.
¤ GD ¤
 
Greatdanes LVL 70 Dwarf Hunter # Professions : Leatherworker
Megabyte LVL 60 Human Paladin # Professions : Mining + Herballism
Ushar LVL 60 Dwarf Priest # Professions : Tailoring + Enchanting
Minimand LVL 60 Gnome Mage # Professions : Alchemy + Engineering
Cæsar LVL 51 Human Rogue # Professions : Herballism + Alchemy
+ some low lvl

Sazgul

Quote from: GreatdanesThe first reply's on Richardi behaviour in this thread was ones again, let's us wait and see what the future will brings...
 
Totally agree Sazgul - a chat with the guy will be a good start.

Well Its settled then, i'll have a diplomatic chat with him.

Mazii

Quote from: GreatdanesWhy can't we give sanctions? We do have a penalty box i the guild, what's that for/to then?
 
Ofc he has to be aware we dislike / will not tolerate his behaviour, but have we done that yet, not as I remember it....even this has being going on for months now.
 
 
I am really surprice by this Mazii - because I know Buford did contact you after the raid last time.

First of all you werent there, which means you don't know that much from the raid :)
 
I left after MC because I had work, and it was in Onyxia's Lair Richardi said he would buff - which I didnt know until Buford contacted me friday evening, not after the raid.

Sazgul

As I see it the following are for him to improve;
 
* His attitude towards others. Reports about him flaming / speaking in a negative way is growing in numbers.
* His slacking in raids (buff) - I was told last raid he should do BoS, and didnt so Daedalus had too.
* He insistet in doing BoL on pallies instead of BoS, which on a healer sounds wrong. Isent BoS
 
So I was planning to tell him that his attitude towards others are causing some unwanted problems within RG2. And asking him about his .. whats it called, view on the current situation.
Then talking a bit with about what he thinks should be buffed in Raids, and what WE want to have buffed in raids.
 
In general have a friendly discussion with him, his views vs. what we want of him, and expect of him.

Greatdanes

I did ask Buford what he think Richardi is doing wrong and here is his answer:
 
QuoteHe bitches over everything and everyone...
he is only focused on loot for himslef (saves dkp even it is a clear rule that he's isnt allowed) we have seen this more than once...
His dispelling is not the best among pallies...
He wants to heal alot even if thats mean overheal, or healing classes that he shouldnt heal...
His buffing depends on whats best for him and not for the raid (clearly shown at OL 03-08-06 where he wanted BoL on paladins insteed of BoS witch is by far most better for the raid, as his job is to mainly heal tanks (and priests))
 
At BWL i noticed him trying to take agro from tank/train by hitting mobs insteed of healing... have only seen him does this once though...
I have asked Buford to make screen shots of it in the future.
 
Okay then Buford must have mix the dates - Mazii.
¤ GD ¤
 
Greatdanes LVL 70 Dwarf Hunter # Professions : Leatherworker
Megabyte LVL 60 Human Paladin # Professions : Mining + Herballism
Ushar LVL 60 Dwarf Priest # Professions : Tailoring + Enchanting
Minimand LVL 60 Gnome Mage # Professions : Alchemy + Engineering
Cæsar LVL 51 Human Rogue # Professions : Herballism + Alchemy
+ some low lvl

Sazgul

Well he didnt listen at all, but pretended to listen, and understand, I felt like we had a good chat, and hoped for the best....
 
But then he did a gquit.
 
Problem solved, maybe the best way...

Nefrion

60 Rogue Nefrion| Class Leader | Defender |
60 Paladin Delle| Alt |
61 Warrior Arc| Alt |