Is there a perfect map?

[Dr Sadako]

Yeah but what? Dust 2, no problem, but Dust is a 'heart dropper' for me.

As I said earlier. It depends on the style of game you are playing. Dust in a match situation it quite fun actually. The map is extremely popular as a DM map. In TCS the map becomes more difficult for T. However, I don't find it impossible. Only last week I played the map and Ts won 10-3 ...

I do agree though, it is not the best TCS map but I could easily think of worse when looking at the standard maps.

[Jewelz^]

Piranisi is the perfect map imo
a) lots of windows to defend the bombsite
b) Bombsites both have multiple levels, making it easiar to attack/defend
c) Tactical Layout is perfect
 
I just love it think its the fairest map regardless of who is on your team, or what team you are on.
Jewelz^

[Jabbs]

Piranisi is the perfect map imo
a) lots of windows to defend the bombsite
b) Bombsites both have multiple levels, making it easiar to attack/defend
c) Tactical Layout is perfect
 
I just love it think its the fairest map regardless of who is on your team, or what team you are on.
Jewelz^

Not bad except the one 'natural' route into B for T's is a death trap :doh:

Of course you could go through middle/top to B but that has dangers because you are going close to A and those routes are usually well defended.

So Piranesi isn't the 'best' map for that reason.  If it consisted of two bomb sites like A, then maybe it would be up there!

[Jewelz^]

So Piranesi isn't the 'best' map for that reason. If it consisted of two bomb sites like A, then maybe it would be up there!

Maybe one of our mappers here at dmw could try and remake pirinesi but change bombsite B to be more accessable maybe

[Jabbs]

Maybe one of our mappers here at dmw could try and remake pirinesi but change bombsite B to be more accessable maybe

Great idea!  Well its a great idea cos it cant be me to remake it!  Come on Doc! Come on Whitey!

[Blunt]

de_Train is perfect:learn:

:withstupid:

[Doorman]

:withstupid:

de_train is..is..is not on my fave list.

[Jewelz^]

de_train is..is..is not on my fave list.

:withstupid: De_train isnt my favourite either.. infact i dont like it at all

[Jabbs]

Technically de_train is a good map but it is not well liked!

• CT's are close to the bomb sites and can get there to defend there quicker than the T's


• T's have three ways into A (left hand site for T's, right for CT's) which is good for them.


• T's have two good ways into B and the possibility of going through the middle towards A and dashing through to B.

But as I said it isn't well liked.  I am not sure why. :crying:

[Jewelz^]

Technically de_train is a good map but it is not well liked!
But as I said it isn't well liked. I am not sure why. :crying:

I find it is too dark
too many trains to get cover
too many small gaps
too many ladders!
:ranting2:

[Lee]

I do like Train, wouldn't say it's the best TCS map though. :narnar:

[T-Bag]

:withstupid:

Quoting yourself...Shameless.

[sod100]

I don't think there is a perfect map but i enjoy most maps

[Jewelz^]

EDIT: didnt mean Piriniesi i meant chateau

[Dr Sadako]

EDIT: didnt mean Piriniesi i meant chateau

Chateau is an interesting map but I wouldn't stretch it as far as to saying it is a perfect map. Bombsite A is regularly only rushed, rarely the side window is used. Who wins on that side is purely down to how CTs defend it. B is a chokepoint and if CTs play it right that chokepoint shouldn't be a problem to guard at all. Middle entrance from water is another chokepoint and CTs have loads of options to cover it. Still this map plays better than e.g. prodigy or italy imo.

Looking at the standard maps I would say that dust2 and piranesi are the most fair maps. Looking at custom maps I would say that e.g. supply, kismayo and nightfever are very even as well.