Concerning legendary items

[Vargen]

But what about for a pallie? And DPS is not the only stats....
 
TL.

Not really the point, as I just wanted to point out that it's not THE super weapon of mass destruction. It has nice damage, and some nice stats. Even has 30 FR. But it should not be totally overpriced. Keep in mind that there will be better weapons in Naxx and maybe even some in AQ40.
The "ooo, shiny" factor is the big thing about this item really. Even if the stats are legendary

[Padding]

If this weapon is to have a high prize, its becoz its hard to get, nothing else really
 
Its like the AH really.... the harder an item to get, the higher the prize will be to buy it on the AH
 
The DKP prize should also ensure that the right person would go for the weapon. I for one wouldnt consider the weapon "need" for me, since its not really healing wise, but if it was free i might go for it, but if it costs me 350DKP then i wouldnt want to spend it really.
 
Conclusion: High prize coz its rare

[KreuZ]

The DKP prize should also ensure that the right person would go for the weapon. I for one wouldnt consider the weapon "need" for me, since its not really healing wise, but if it was free i might go for it, but if it costs me 350DKP then i wouldnt want to spend it really.
 
Conclusion: High prize coz its rare

How would we need a high price for it because of that? The officers are deciding who gets the legendarys anyway so that has nothing to do with it.

[Padding]

Just becoz we decide who gets it, then its free? That makes absolutely no sense at all, its still the hardest thing to get and if you want that.... pay the prize

[KreuZ]

I never said it should be free because we decide, I said DKP price shouldn't be set because it would make only people that really wanted it to get it, since we officers decide who gets it. DKP price can still be set on the item for being legendary, but the former reason is just ridiculous.

[Vargen]

If items cost after how rare they are, Stormrage legguards would be sick expensive. Not to mention Trancendace in BWL :narnar:

[Padding]

If items cost after how rare they are, Stormrage legguards would be sick expensive. Not to mention Trancendace in BWL

DOH.... its the probable drop the chance, not how lucky we are as a guild
 
Could we please agree on a prize.... im gonna be a bit lenient and say 300 (plus maybe some materials) to accomodate all sides...
 
Is that something we all can agree on? Somebody got a drop last night as well from what i hear, so we need to agree NOW :taz:

[TeaLeaf]

We need to conclude this issue now as we have 2 items on DKP at zero value now after the Eye dropped again for RG2 last night.

I concede the stats issue, but I still think that it's value should be at BWL weapon level.  It is a Legendary item and therefore I propose that amongst our range of views (where the Eye could be anything from FREE to 350DKP) that we adopt a value in line with Epic Weapons from BWL:

Eye of Sulfurus = DKP value of 260 DKP.

This is the compromise I propose.  Please could we now conclude this matter today so that the DKP site can be properly updated.

TL.

[Bastet]

id go for 280, since its better then BWL (who's 2h are 240-260) and if we all agree, il update dkp later

[Vargen]

Let's say 280 then. And should we maybe deduct it when the weapon is done crafted, or as the legendary drop is handed out? Keep in mind that for Thunderfury you need two parts of a legendary drop and not to mention Ateish with 42 drops.

[Bastet]

for eye, on hand out, for TF on craft id say.
 
As soon as some more officers agree to this + dkp cost ill change

[TeaLeaf]

Agreed, 280 it is then.

TL.

[Bastet]

Padding also agreed via msn, so ill be changing values now