Ninja_Freak - Further action?

Anonymous · December 19, 2005, 11:42:55 AM

Nothing to add TL. Our rules would seem to be being complied with. However, the vote is split 4 for demotion and 4 for warning so we need a deciding/casting vote just to be squeeky clean I would guess.

TeaLeaf · December 19, 2005, 12:14:22 PM

I took the deciding vote to be the 3 members who voted for demotion to Alpha. So I figured that the majority voted for demotion and that this was the view that would carry the day 7 - 4. In my PM to him I intend to include a summary of the vote, not identifying any person, but things like the 7-4, to allow him to understand the impact his outburst has had on the community and its Admins.

TL.

Anonymous · December 19, 2005, 01:18:00 PM

QuoteOriginally posted by TeaLeaf@Dec 19 2005, 12:14 PM
I took the deciding vote to be the 3 members who voted for demotion to Alpha. So I figured that the majority voted for demotion and that this was the view that would carry the day 7 - 4. In my PM to him I intend to include a summary of the vote, not identifying any person, but things like the 7-4, to allow him to understand the impact his outburst has had on the community and its Admins.

TL.
[post=105935]Quoted post[/post]
[/b]

Much clearer now. Happy with that decision!

OldBloke · December 19, 2005, 07:01:54 PM

I'm happy too.

We will need to consider the question of how and when he can re-apply for Charlie (if he wants to) and incorporating that into the rules.

TeaLeaf · December 19, 2005, 09:23:58 PM

QuoteMessage Forwarded From TeaLeaf

Ninja, thanks for being patient.

The Admins reviewed your reaction to the banning from our BF2 server and considered several options as to how to proceed. The options ranged from a 'do nothing' to an outright ban from the dMw servers. Each option was debated and the Admins finally signed off an agreement this evening.

The bottom line was that the Admins were extremely shocked by your reaction and insistence on using the forums as a place to publically debate and make allegations (proven or not proven). It was not the actions we expected from a member of the community and certainly not of one from Charlie Company.

The Admins voted 7-4 to demote you to a lower Company. The decision as to whether to demote you to Alpha Company (and therefore lose your dMw wings) or to Bravo Company was somewhat closer with demotion to Bravo Company winning by a single vote.

Regretably, the decision is therefore to demote you to Bravo Company.

We do not wish you to leave the community, indeed we would not even rule out accepting you back into Charlie Company at some point in the future should you choose to apply, but the decision does represent how seriously the Admins viewed your public airing of what shoudl have been an adult and private exchange of views as per the Member Standards.

I have already changed your forum grouping and want to assure you that I have no intention of publicising the demotion on the forums unless you choose to do so.

I hope you understand this decision and hope to see you on the servers tonight. You have a contribution to make to the community and we would welcome it again.

TL.

Anonymous · December 19, 2005, 09:34:20 PM

As ever, nicely worded TL. Thanks for doing all the hard work on this one :clap:

OldBloke · December 19, 2005, 10:31:07 PM

He's gifted I tell ya :thumb:

TeaLeaf · December 20, 2005, 09:23:15 AM

Clearly there's still some anymosity here, but what they hey, it's Christmas so let's move on.

TL.

QuoteMessage Forwarded From TeaLeaf

QuoteOriginally posted by Ninja_Freak

I think it's weak..

L8rs
Ninja, as the bearer of the message I'm sorry you feel that way.

I am hoping that some good old time will heal the wounds that both sides of the argument feel the have had inflicted upon them.

See you on the servers.

TL.

[/b]

TeaLeaf · December 20, 2005, 11:18:43 AM

QuoteOriginally posted by Ninja_Freak
Me too but for now....

Hopefully things will be different at LAN-time...