Application process - CANCELD - Please see Poll 2

Started by Bastet, October 14, 2007, 01:15:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Bastet

Sujestion: Do away with the application process to improve inflow into the guild to boost activity and numbers for gruul/second raid group faster. The risk of rotten apples will be taken, these will be removed.
 
This poll will run for 5 days, no vote cast will default to agree, over half agrees accepts the above.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Othbarty

How would we do it then? Invite whoever wants to join? I dont think that is a good idea tbh.. We could remove the form and still get the members to comment on it, then move it into officers as a poll same as thisone. Just with a lower runtime?
-=[dMw]=-Othbarty  ::  Mighty Cheese Event
"Trust the awesomeness!"
- Skippy the Magnificent

Bastet

Invite all that would make a good adition to the guild, like from the classes we require for raiding.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Gorion

whatever the dire need is, this goes against the principles sog has had since i can remember
 
reducing the time needed to get an application through is one thing and i strongly agree to it
 
opening up the gates to any interested player is needed or not is something else, even if the player is kicked after
 
i will never aceppt this, and it doesnt matter who votes in favour or not - this will never happen
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

Lucian

I can see both sides of the argument here.  We need to GREATLY reduce the application time process in order to expedite applications and fill up our membership.
 
On the other hand, this does reduce a large degree of officer collegiality and ultimately Gorion's authority.
 
As the poll stands, I am in favour of it.  
 
As an aside: we are a little like Ancient Rome.  The ruling classes (social elite) there found themselves slowly decaying from within: by refusing to allow newcomers to the grouping, over time natural attrition meant that the size of the body began to decline. Change was needed - how to allow new members in, what makes a new member etc.  SOG needs a transfusion of new blood, and that needs to be quickly done.
 
Gorion: how would you feel about opening up the gates for either a) a limited amount of time (say two weeks) or b) until we hit thirty active members?
 
Once either of those criteria is reached we return to our current established systems.
 
By the way, I also interpret Bastet's idea as offering places to those seen advertising in general chat channels.
AKA Bobbyus
 

Gorion

we should set a number of everyclass that we could invite say, 3-4 per class to get newblood in
 
but the usual application process must be upheld
 
re application time shortening, i just posted in th e gruuls thread and yes, it is needed
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

Bastet

at the moment the time it takes for us to process the applications is hurting us since members that are looking for active guilds will rarely wait the 5 days for us to get back to them.
 
If all officers can offer places we will get where we want to be a hell of a lot quicker. After we get there we can go back to our old system and weed out the not so good players.
 
IF we carry on like we do now we will die out in a relatively medium therm.
 
Also, Gorion, i dont think its fair for you to block a majority vote off officers. This system is by no means ideal, but neither is our current one. And we need to get some fresh blood in the guild fast, if we are to leave karazhan behind us in a relatively timely manner.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Gorion

there are other ways to do it, like as you said, drastically decreasing the application process time.
 
officers can still offer places, if they see someone in /1 they can point them out to our site were they can signup and then be approved or not
 
simply inviting is a no go, unfair how it is
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

Bastet

Still to long, i strongly urge towards cutting it down not to days, but to hours. We simply cannot wait 48 hours.
 
Edit, merged with other relavent topic, so we dont get 5 threads dicussing the same.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Gorion

dont merge any threads without asking please, its a different discussion, and whatever vote is taken on the immediate invite issue will be null
 
as i said, it wont happen and its totally out of the question
Guild Wars 2 - Characters: Dragelis / Estril / Viliona
Battle.net - LydonB#2167
Warframe - LydonB

Bastet

What happens or not is not upto you alone, but rather to us as a group. Majority vote rules. If you want to play dictator, fine, but i doubt ill be arround long then.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)

Othbarty

#11
at the merging of threads, this should be done at the moderators/officers discretion, and we should not need permission to do so. If you feel the current moderators cant do that, i would like for you/TL to remove my moderation privleges as they would only be for show. Asking you for permission is a waste of time tbh...

How about this, when there is a new member wanting to join, if there is three officers online at the time who agree on the player joining, he could get a invite. If there is not three members online at the time, a poll should be created in the forums, requiering three officers votes to accept, this should be doable in a couple of hrs, or a day at most. I do feel that Gorion (Being the GM) should be able to invite ppl at his own discretion, however should not kick ppl without either a VERY good reason (being abusive/ninja looting etc) or without two fellow officers concent. (This would go for the other officers aswell) Perhaps four votes should be required but not more. If a conserned member lets us know about a problem with a initiate, this should be investigated by the recieving officer (Or the officer in charge of that) and the member with the conserne should be held up to speed with the progress.
-=[dMw]=-Othbarty  ::  Mighty Cheese Event
"Trust the awesomeness!"
- Skippy the Magnificent

Soon Jung

SoonJung Gunslinger Girl

My life consists of Welsh fountains and frozen shampoo.

I\'m not crazy. My reality just differ from yours.

TeaLeaf

Let's not keep upping the ante please, it helps nobody.

Discuss the issue, try not to rule anything out.  That's why it is a discussion.  

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Bastet

3 officer consent could work, but id trust any of you to make the right call by yourselfs.
Aszune (Alliance):
Sokhar lv 80 (H/M) Warrior, Sokhár lv 80 (H/M) Death Knight, Beset lv 70 (NE/F) Druid, Bastet lv 70 (NE/F) Rogue, Mentu lv 70 (Dr/M) Shaman
-=[dMw]=-Bastet (CSS) / -=[dMw]=-Niwa (BF2) / -=dMw=- Sokhar (BF2142)
-=[dMw]=- MVP Award Holder (June 2006) Winning team -=[dMw]=- Christmas Crunch (2008)