AFIs Top 10 Lists of Top 10s

[Anonymous]

The American Film Institute (AFI) has released its list of top 10 films in 10 different genre's. feel free to argue/discuss/ROFL

http://www.happynews.com/news/6182008/best-10-afi-releases-top-10-genre-film-lists.htm

[TeaLeaf]

Personal favourites from that list (and god there are some awful choices out there even in terms of assigned category):

FANTASY

2. ''The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring,'' 2001.

6. ''Field of Dreams,'' 1989.

8. ''Groundhog Day,'' 1993.

GANGSTER

1. ''The Godfather,'' 1972.

3. ''The Godfather Part II,'' 1974.

7. ''Pulp Fiction,'' 1994.

SCIENCE FICTION

4. ''A Clockwork Orange,'' 1971.

5. ''The Day The Earth Stood Still,'' 1951.

6. ''Blade Runner,'' 1982.

7. ''Alien,'' 1979.

8. ''Terminator 2: Judgment Day,'' 1991.


SPORTS


ROMANTIC COMEDY

6. ''When Harry Met Sally ...,'' 1989.

COURTROOM DRAMA

1. ''To Kill a Mockingbird,'' 1962.

2. ''12 Angry Men,'' 1957.

5. ''A Few Good Men,'' 1992.

EPIC

2. ''Ben-Hur,'' 1959.

5. ''Spartacus,'' 1960.

8. ''Saving Private Ryan,'' 1998.

[Anonymous]

I was gobsmacked at Back to the future making it in there :blink:

[ChimpBoy]

I fail to see how you can have a Westerns category featuring none of the Dollars trilogy or Once Upon A Time in the West :g:

Also, yes 2001: A Space Odyssey is a fine piece of art from Kubrick, but it's the sort of film that really doesn't invite repeat viewing and would never make an audiences top ten of sci-fi.

In my opinion that's why the choices here are so poor, as TL said - too much focus on the art, and not enough on the entertainment.

P.S. don't knock BTTF BB - I adored that film when it was released, and still do.  Timeless fun  The sequels are ropey, but the original is a classic.

[delanvital]

I was gobsmacked at Back to the future making it in there :blink:

Why? :blink:

I fail to see how you can have a Westerns category featuring none of the Dollars trilogy or Once Upon A Time in the West :g:

Once Upon... - I absolutely agree. It is in my top 10 (with the whole list currently containing 1551 films . That movie intro is the best ever. And then this dialogue as the bad guys at the train station are about to leave, when they realise Bronson actually got off the train, but on the other side. As the train moves away, he stands there, and the three goons opposite.

Harmonica: And Frank?  
 Snaky: Frank sent us.  
 Harmonica: Did you bring a horse for me?  
 Snaky: Well... looks like we're...  
[snickers]  
 Snaky: ...looks like we're shy one horse.  
 Harmonica: You brought two too many.

No need to say what happens from there :flirty:

[ChimpBoy]

Snaky: ...looks like we're shy one horse.  
 Harmonica: You brought two too many.

One of my favorite parts from any film ever.  Hearing that short harmonica tune makes the hairs on my neck stand up every time.

Also, in the final gunfight:
Harmonica: So, you found out you're not a businessman after all.
Frank: Just a man.

Wonderful film.