Main Menu

Anti cheat team

Started by KKND, November 18, 2011, 03:48:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

KKND

Why dont have whe a Anti cheat team inside the Community?
With games like BF3 whe are getting new people that wanna join the Community and play BF3.
Maybe scan these peeps first before they can join.
It´s for a good case,as whe dont want that dMw name gets infect.

smilodon

We use a similar system for forum access to catch spammers and bots before they do any damage. However it's quite straight forward as we have a 'go-to' resource on the web. Is there something similar for games i.e. a searchable database of player names, emails and IP addresses we can check against?
smilodon
Whatever's gone wrong it's not my fault.

KKND

You can scan people if they have Steamid.
It scans for Ban(s),cheats,hacks ect etc.

I know not every BF3 player have a Steam account,but it wont hurt to do some research first before accepting people...
If you look at the BP bans BF3,then i think it's good to do some about it.

Tutonic

Is it really worth the effort?

If someone's ID is banned for cheating, then they won't be able to join any of our servers anyway (I assume we enable VAC/Punkbuster/Whatever on all our game servers) - so why would they be looking to join?

Plus we have no way of determining if they were previously banned under a different name/ID.
Hero of the Battle Of Chalkeia
"Don\'t worry, none of this blood is mine"



TeaLeaf

I'm inclined to agree with Tutonic.   Cheaters are far less likely to want to register here and become part fo the community, they will jump from server to server anonymously having their illicit fun.  I would conclude it is not worth any effort due to the number of routes available to avoid any checks we do here in dMw.   Registering on the forums does not give them our wings, so our name is not being muddied.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

ArithonUK

There is, in ProCon, a plug-in called "Meta bans" which checks players against a global banned player list. People are added to this list when banned on other servers subscribing to the service.

Maybe we could look into this?

TeaLeaf

That's a question to raise in the BF3 GA section Arithon as it relates solely to BF3 rather than the whole of dMw.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

TheDvEight

Surely it would be easy enough to check peoples stats before they are accepted i know with bc2, bf2 and bf3 there was stats websites which where it was pretty easy to tell if someone was cheating
"Mira Mira on the wall who\'s the fairest of them all?" - Dickdastardly "it\'ll sting a lot" - Lesion

TeaLeaf

Quote from: .DickDastardly.;337839Surely it would be easy enough to check peoples stats before they are accepted i know with bc2, bf2 and bf3 there was stats websites which where it was pretty easy to tell if someone was cheating
Accepted to what?  I think we're missing the point here?

1. Someone registers on the forum - no problem whomever they are (unless we ban them for spamming) and we have no other info to go on and they wear no wings

2. The GL awards someone their wings within the game - they are already known to the community and have a record on our server, forums and TS.

The former has no use for additional checks due to what Tutonic has already said.
The latter is a BF3-specific issue and not a system that can be applied across dMw, so should be in the BF3 GA section not in this forum topic and is probably, for the same reasons, of limited use.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

KKND

Quote from: TeaLeaf;337852Accepted to what?  I think we're missing the point here?

1. Someone registers on the forum - no problem whomever they are (unless we ban them for spamming) and we have no other info to go on and they wear no wings

2. The GL awards someone their wings within the game - they are already known to the community and have a record on our server, forums and TS.

The former has no use for additional checks due to what Tutonic has already said.
The latter is a BF3-specific issue and not a system that can be applied across dMw, so should be in the BF3 GA section not in this forum topic and is probably, for the same reasons, of limited use.

It was just a idea nothing more,point taken!!