Trial Loot System Feedback

DonnieKingo · November 07, 2006, 09:43:46 AM

Quote from: Bob;161533Sorry to disappoint you DK, but that logic of yours won't hold at all.

Now I don't know about the dps-list, but from my own exlperience in the healing-list, your position on that list doesn't neccesarily have anything to do with what gear you have.

And also, that'll just open up for people thinking "Hey, I need some new gear today, so I think I'll just take it easy and slack a bit through the raid"

Thats why i said that it wasnt easy as "some people might just put their char on auto-attack and sit back and wait for the upgrades" and that not everyone is equally specced - therefor not doing comparable damage

Sinap · November 08, 2006, 01:00:36 AM

Quote from: Bob;161533And also, that'll just open up for people thinking "Hey, I need some new gear today, so I think I'll just take it easy and slack a bit through the raid"

No loot for me ever then

xD

Knabbel · November 08, 2006, 06:13:31 AM

Quote from: Sinap;161666No loot for me ever then xD

ROFL :roflmao:

Even doing nothing he is on top of the damage meters!!! :roflmao:

Then the rest of the raid is wairing grey items?

Luthor · November 12, 2006, 04:14:11 PM

Next question is, when are these lootrules removed again, afterall they were on trial. i dont think they made it

Vargen · November 12, 2006, 04:53:55 PM

It's on the last trial week. Personally I think it failed misserably. Maybe I would have liked it if I were a rogue...

Nebuoh · November 12, 2006, 05:07:54 PM

pff.. another week... I do would like to know what the next loot system will be... dkp * priority scaling? or are we going back to the old system... or are we gonna wait who will do /gquit to determine the next system... (and no I won't take back anything I have mentioned about this in the past about anybody or any system)

Gorion · November 12, 2006, 05:31:32 PM

well, my oppinion is.. we dont need all this. the old system is good enough..

the only thing that ppl should solve is the "infighting" over items crap, fex. rg1 warriors dont have this "infighting problem", and afaik we never had problems with eachother..

so imho its not the system thats problematic.. its the ppl

this is just lack of co-operation with eachother..

if you want something real bad, save dkp.
talk about it in your class channel, and if youre that desperate.. request a favour, it might be denied.. but hey, if he/she has more dkp then you, it means that he/she worked harder than you

i might get bashed.. but i dont care.. its the truth, suck it up and face it

Gallahan · November 12, 2006, 07:45:13 PM

^^agree with Gorion.

DKP=KING imho

Yrthal · November 12, 2006, 10:38:05 PM

Quote from: Gorion;162382well, my oppinion is.. we dont need all this. the old system is good enough..

the only thing that ppl should solve is the "infighting" over items crap, fex. rg1 warriors dont have this "infighting problem", and afaik we never had problems with eachother..

so imho its not the system thats problematic.. its the ppl

this is just lack of co-operation with eachother..

if you want something real bad, save dkp.
talk about it in your class channel, and if youre that desperate.. request a favour, it might be denied.. but hey, if he/she has more dkp then you, it means that he/she worked harder than you

i might get bashed.. but i dont care.. its the truth, suck it up and face it

Agree!! :rockon:

ratatosk · November 13, 2006, 08:43:34 AM

Gorion u are right!

But the problem aint inbetween ur own class! like warriors Hunters dont have any problem we always talk about loot! one exception though Ashjen and the Xbow, but according to himself it was just the final drop that made his cup spill!
The problem are still between classes who benefits most from an item???

But i agree let DKP Rule and deal with it! and hope that ppl use common sence!

Best regards Rata

Incentos · November 13, 2006, 09:26:18 AM

Quote from: Vargen;162379It's on the last trial week. Personally I think it failed misserably. Maybe I would have liked it if I were a rogue...

Can we plz stop the rogue hate thingy....its getting annoying.

StrontiumDog · November 13, 2006, 09:32:10 AM

I don't think he meant it in that way mate, just simply this trial system benefits dps classes more than others.

ratatosk · November 13, 2006, 09:56:51 AM

:huggy: Incentos i dont hate U!

Zabard · November 13, 2006, 10:00:06 AM

Well, with the response on this thread, I've got a much better picture of what trouble the commanders and officers have had with this before. Whatever is best for you guys is all I have to say. Perhaps leave this thread here as a "warning" for future demands of change in loot systems.

Yrthal · November 13, 2006, 04:08:27 PM

Quote from: Incentos;162461Can we plz stop the rogue hate thingy....its getting annoying.

Its not hate.. if you see whatever drops with agi, str, crit aso.
It all goes to a rogue.
Druids, hunters, warriors, pallys are back in line..!

then comes the discussion who does it benefit more!?

I say highest dkp is the best way...!
Either is it a Druid, pally, hunter or warrior, depends on DKP and rest can suck on a thumb untill its drops again!

There is a reason why ppl have much dkp.. they have been there all the way..

Yeah some got 10k dkp and others got -200 dkp thats just bad luck... Raid, raid and raid and then get your item.

Highest dkp + Common sense is the best lootrule ever!
Allways remember to think outside the box.