Match Feedback - de_aztec - 15/05/03 (v evul)

Started by TeaLeaf, May 15, 2003, 11:17:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

TeaLeaf

Copy of the Clanbase match report that I submitted.

TL.  8)

QuoteTeam: Radman Squonk SLowhand Sadako TeaLeaf

After waiting 10 or so for evul's 5th player (his Mum said he was asleep in bed, but they git him out for the match anyway) we played a good knife round for a change and actuall won! That should have been the writing on the wall for us really.

As CT we sucked better than a Dyson and went down (much as Gillian Tailforth did) 2-10. As T we proved that we were multi-talented, if only by showing that we could blow as well as suck. We lost 4-8 on that half :(

evul were a heck of a sight better team than their 813 points ranking. They should be several hundred points higher by my estimation. Unfortunately, we are a true 700 range clan and we suffered big stylee to a far better clan.

evul - can I offer you some advice?  Get you ferkin act together! Confused? Let me explain by pointing some things out to you:

- We asked for WONIDs as a requirement of the match.
- I even reminded you to get your players WONIDs registered an hour and a half before the match by coming to your IRC room.
- Only 3 members of your clan have registered their WONIDs.
- Against us tonight you played like a 1200 point clan when you have a rating of 813 points. We have played and lost enough matches to recognise the difference.
- You play only 2 players whose WONIDs match the CB database.
- You play 1 player who has not registered his WONID with CB.
- You play 1 player who has not even registered with your clan, let alone CB or his WONID.
- You play another player who has registered his WONID with CB, but his match WONID is different.

This might make some people think that you used 'mercs'.

Many other clans would have entered match conflict after all of the above. Had we entered a match conflict you would without any doubt at all have lost the result, so all your hard work would be for nought. However a match conflict is not our way, so we have accepted the result. But for goodness sake, get your act together and get register your players and their WONIDs. A lesser clan than us would have kicked off about your transgressions and that would be a shame for such a young clan.

GL in the future - I am sure that even with registered players and WONIDs you will still be a darn sight higher in the rankings than us :)
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Dr Sadako

:D

Told you that something wasn't right. ;)

Very good job TL!!!
-=[dMw]=-Dr "Doc" Sadako

"Gravitation is not responsible for people falling in love." Albert Einstein

OldBloke

He's good at this isn't he?

Top job TL. :thumbsup:
"War without end. Well, what was history if not that? And how would having the stars change anything?" - James S. A. Corey

TeaLeaf

Their reply:

QuoteFirst of all, good game - it was fun.

We did really well as T. Individually, we all did pretty good. However, teamwork was a little off. Communication needs work.

When we were CT, it went off even more, our teamwork that is. It got a little sloppy, but we somehow managed to hold it together and win 8-4.

I must apologise on behalf of Penguin, he is actually Possum. He had decided on the name change a while ago, but had never got round to updating his ClanBase profile. All the other points TeaLeaf raised were true also, but I'm not too sure which player had a mismatched WONID. Care to verify this with me if possible?

All I can say is, we're an honest clan. None of us cheat, nor would we get outside players to play for us in an official match. This is only my word though, so whether or not you take it is up to you.

Thanks for not taking this matter further by not registering a match conflict. I appreciate it.

We all had fun, and I hope your clan had fun too.

P.S. We DO need to get our act together, my clan are a bunch of lazy bastards
:o

My response:

QuoteGoldfish played with WONID 3143174 whereas his CB WONID is 3011488. I have screenshots etc if you need them, although I am sure that is not necessary.

We more than accept your word that you only played your own players and not mercs. I was just trying to point out that a lot of other clans would not be so lenient! You can see from our own membership page that all bar 2 players have their WONIDs registered - and one of those is new to the clan this week. Unfortunately we recently played such a clan and purely by accident we fielded a registered player who had not yet added his WONID. It was a fair and close match with no question of cheating, but the other clan still kicked off about it afterwards and registered a match conflict - our first ever! This despite being all sweetness and light on the server.

So it was really just a heads up for you - you are good enough (and I see that you thought you guys played a poor game, :::eek:: that if you play other clans at this points level and play them like you did us (or better) then they will be sorely tempted to match conflict if your WONIDs are not registered when WONIDs have been specified as a challenge condition. If you collect match conflicts along the way your reputation goes down the pan and people will not want to play you.

Your reputation in the ladder is paramount, so good luck in getting the other peeps to get their 'decaying vegetable matter' together

All the best in the ladder.......!

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

albert

Did they curse and swear a lot a and omg/wtf or whatever?

I would have made and example of them since you'd gone to the trouble of gathering all this evidence it obviously bothered you enough. I know it's just a game and all that but in the end they'll just do it next match anyway.

Sounds like I was lucky not to play last night.  :?
Cheers, Bert