Main Menu

FIA Decision

Started by Lameduck, September 07, 2008, 06:14:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Doorman

I thought that was so silly it didn't need a smiley. :rolleyes: I'll watch that in future.










     

Aquilifer

They should have used Doorman's patent solution - place few red-white barriers 'o death into the chicane and no more cutting :rolleyes:
(if not played LFS, you prolly don't understand this)


...although then Lewis would have become the first black person to visit the moon :g:

Doorman

Quote from: Aquilifer;243906They should have used Doorman's patent solution - place few red-white barriers 'o death into the chicane and no more cutting :rolleyes:
(if not played LFS, you prolly don't understand this)
See how quickly my lads learn. :D










     

spudgun55

lol :roflmao:
Quote from: Aquilifer;243906They should have used Doorman's patent solution - place few red-white barriers 'o death into the chicane and no more cutting :rolleyes:
(if not played LFS, you prolly don't understand this)


...although then Lewis would have become the first black person to visit the moon :g:
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

Armitage

After the dullness of Valencia we get a humginger in Belgium. I was jumping up and down for the last few laps and once all over was reconfirmed as an F1 fan.


Then the FIA spoil the party because there Ferrari didn't win. He is appealing. But feel like jacking it all and start watching Tennis. Go Andy:norty:

Read about the appeal here
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/motorsport/formula_one/7603179.stm

Jabbs

Quote from: Armitage;243925After the dullness of Valencia we get a humginger in Belgium. I was jumping up and down for the last few laps and once all over was reconfirmed as an F1 fan.
 
 
Then the FIA spoil the party because there Ferrari didn't win. He is appealing. But feel like jacking it all and start watching Tennis. Go Andy:norty:
 
Read about the appeal here
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/motorsport/formula_one/7603179.stm

Thanks for the linky :g:
Start Folding and get yourself one of those nice new badge thingies, it\'s a good cause.  Check out the stats

[email]jabbs@deadmen.co.uk[/email]

TeaLeaf

I have to say I was astonished at the FIA ruling.

Using the usual FIA logic:  
nobody got hurt so it wasn't dangerous.......err, sorry that was the logic for the previous race, let me just get the current race logic which as an equivalent to the previous race must surely be:  it did not affect the outcome of the race as Kimi tanked it into the wall.  Ergo Lewis gained no advantage and should therefore not be penalised.  Lewis wins. QED.

Using everybody else's logic:
-Lewis entered the chicane ahead of Kimi
-Kimi outbraked himself and Lewis had to leave the track or be in a train wreck
-Lewis could either rejoin the circuit immediately and crash into Kimi by going over the kerbs, or cut across the corner (he chose the latter)
-Lewis yield track position by the start/finish line and crossed that line some 6 kmph slower than Kimi.
-Kimi moved more than once to defend the line into corner 1 but Lewis switched on him and easily outbraked him into the turn
-Lewis got hit by Kimi again

None of the above gave Lewis an advantage under the rules.  Afaiaa the rules say to yield the position, they do not say 'yield the position and give the guy a 5 second lead on you to make it absolutely fair'.  Tbh Lewis could have given Kimi a 10 second lead and he still would have won as Kimi + Ferrari + rain = pants.

I'm failing to see the logic in the decision they reached and the penalty they applied.  It beggars belief.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Armitage

Your forgetting, Red is the FIA's favorite colour.:ranting2::crying::g:

Zootoxin

The thing I don't understand is this -

Didn't Lewis win the race because Kimi span out? as he was in front due to the back marker holding LH up and Kimi took pole?

TeaLeaf

Lewis had pole.  But yes, Kimi in the wet managed to tank it.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

spudgun55

Damon Hill on radio 2 this morning called it a very close call?:g:
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

Lexander

I have to correct...  
Quote from: TeaLeaf;243930Hard tires + Ferrari + rain = pants.
Because all went prefect before the last tires change (from 4 position to 1 and leading the whole race) and also Massa said that the hard tires were not getting a good grip and it was hard to drive with them => hard tires + rain  = fail.

And about the +25sec, I read that lewis would have got a "drive through pit" penalty if there was more laps left, but as the race ended it was turned to a +25seconds.
Welcome to IRC #deadmen @quakenet

TeaLeaf

Quote from: Lexander;243952I have to correct...  
  Because all went prefect before the last tires change (from 4 position to 1 and leading the whole race) and also Massa said that the hard tires were not getting a good grip and it was hard to drive with them => hard tires + rain  = fail.

And about the +25sec, I read that lewis would have got a "drive through pit" penalty if there was more laps left, but as the race ended it was turned to a +25seconds.
If he had taken the drive through he could have done it in the pit lane and won the race (a la Schumacher), although I am sure that particular German cheat has since been outlawed.

As for wet weather performance.  They were both on hard tyres and Kimi sucks compared to Lewis in the wet.  If you want additional 'option' tyre reference material, check out the last wet race where on both sets of tyres Kimi sucked compared to Lewis.  In fact the last really wet race where inters were used, Kimi sucked on that too.  And yes, Massa & rain do not go well together either in general.

TL.
TL.
Wisdom doesn\'t necessarily come with age. Sometimes age just shows up all by itself.  (Tom Wilson)
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships. (Michael Jordan)

Snokio

Its mainly to do with the combination of Ferrari's longer wheel base and unable to maintain heat in the tires in rain conditions. The rules do state that if a competitor gains an advantage over an opponent when taking a non racing line, they will be given a penalty (+25 seconds is the standard time rather one they pluck out of the air)

Still harsh, and I hope they win their appeal!
​ Bring on the randomness!
Apparently I actually exist! Or maybe it was the drink?

Doorman

I'm beginning to not give a toss any more. :angry:





Scrub that, I don't give a toss any more. :D