Not Like This

[Gandalf]

I don't agree with this method. I consider it bullying. Issues should be resolved individually, between the eyes of the raider and the class leader. That's why I rather have the CLs take care of it before people are starting to shout out names on the forum, on TS or in raid chat.

I agree with Mezzanine here. Name and shame is not the way, all it will serve to do is alienate people which will hurt the guild more than help.

The whole reason I brought in the class leaders is to identify members that need improvement and to discuss with them, either via whispers in game or via PM on the forum. Then if that person needs spec or rotation advice, we have the class forums to ask for advice in.

[smite]

I bring you options....it's up to you if you use them. :flirty:
 
Depends what level you want to acheive, the guild was originally set up as part of the community a fun, social place to go for like minded people, meeting a happy medium between a relaxed happy place but acheiving high end goals was never going to be easy.
 
Also remember theres nowt wrong with a good bit of ribbing :narnar:

[Mezzanine]

Personally I believe you can combine a fun, friendly guild with a disciplined raiding environment. Compare it to any team sport.

Also remember theres nowt wrong with a good bit of ribbing :narnar:

I'll remember that if I ever meet you. :narnar:

[Spaceinvader]

Very interesting reading i must say..

Jumped a few replies so i might repeat other ppls. comments, for a start, i totally agree with Garrit, ive too often been really frustrated on some of our raids, bosses that went down easily the week before become a wipefest. Honestly I do make noob mistakes sometimes, i think we all do, but generally the problem is people NOT looking at utube videos for the bossfights..Thats one primary mistake among too many people i think.
 Secondly i see some, not alot but a good handfull of people or more that seriously underperform, despite their excellent gear. Solution? Well theres 2 and a half here.
1 lets be honest, at least the officers knows whos is underperforming, DONT invite them for raids. Its harsh i know but it doesnt take more than 2-3 underperformers to ruin a raid evening. DONT invite them simple as that. We have a good 30-40 people online on raid nights now, if its still not enough invite a few more good players to guild.
2 I know theres already some macro info on site, but maybe we need to elaborate to people on those macros for diffrent toons. I dunno maybe some training evenings. I got tought by a Hunter named Fragga. He spent a whole hour training my shot rotations. I myself skipped macros completely since i noticed an increase in dps, but for others they might be salvation, who knows.
And that last half i really dont want to see happening, we make a DMR elite guild. for the elite performers, maybe an option for people to swap back and forth as gear, time, RL etc. allows..point it u gotta make urself earned to stay there. Backside is it might split the guild totally hence why i dont really want this option.

Sry for my poor english btw.

Space

[Deminion]

oh god space, was in guild with Fragga when he lvl'ed, he was known as the HunterTank. Don't do that, please :narnar:

[Spaceinvader]

Ur not the first who tells me that, :g: well it worked for me. Think the guy changed cause I was impressed by his skill in pug action and he definately boosted my dps with that training

Space