Here we go again.

Menedil · October 06, 2006, 11:13:58 PM

brut blade is a better offhand than maladeth unless its a boss fight.

but your point is valid.

Quote from: Vargen;154805Well, soon enough those will be traded for Maladath, Runed Blade of the Black Flight and Chromatically Tempered Sword. But the hunter will still be using his Brutality blade.

Vargen · October 07, 2006, 12:02:44 AM

Besides, if that blade was that important to you, why weren't you top DKP then? You can't have everything at once. If I really wanted something that wasn't class spesific, I would wait with getting my class spesific items till I had gotten the non class spesific item. Less competiton less frustration though you might be stuck with the same armor for a while. Right now, that isn't a problem for me at least, since I'm not really in a hurry to get rid of my lovely tier 2 untill Dreamwalker reinment starts showing up.

Vargen · October 07, 2006, 12:04:08 AM

Quote from: Menedil;154809brut blade is a better offhand than maladeth unless its a boss fight.

but your point is valid.

As he pulled the "Raid benefit" card, it is a valid point in deed :flirty:

JanuZ · October 07, 2006, 01:01:00 AM

Actually any raid fight the maldath is better since more then 50% of the raid fights are lvl63+ and unless you are human or have weapon expertise the +skill helps alot on the 62 fights also.

For how hard or easy it is to track what item should go to what class it is very simple and a ML should know it for about 95% of the loot that goes out just by looking on the item if unsure he could check this site

http://www.wow-loot.com

And it is very simple common sence doesn't work well when the person using it is involved in the matter since objectivity dissapears.

Sinap · October 07, 2006, 06:31:27 AM

Sorry but like.... its a BRUTALITY BLADE, wait till next week and it'll drop again, think this is being blown a little out of proportion here, sure, if it was a legendary, maybe make a post, but jesus, you have this guy on farm, just wait a week or whatever.

shadowscream · October 07, 2006, 06:35:48 AM

Quote from: Sinap;154827Sorry but like.... its a BRUTALITY BLADE, wait till next week and it'll drop again, think this is being blown a little out of proportion here, sure, if it was a legendary, maybe make a post, but jesus, you have this guy on farm, just wait a week or whatever.

not everyone raids every week, and not exactly farm status, we RG2 decided that it was time we do BWL so the MC we did was a sidekick due to lack of certain classes BWL got canceled that night.
legendary, epic doesn't matter the act it self matters.

Greatdanes · October 07, 2006, 06:52:02 AM

Quote from: shadowscream;154828not everyone raids every week.

Why should they have the weapon then, if you not raiding every time, then it will not benefit the raid?

Knabbel · October 07, 2006, 08:29:06 AM

Point made GD.

I realy don't like to see such a post like this because it will bring tentions into the raid group, and we must get a solid group....

Jemeny, plz reconsider and you'll get your BB or better in the near future.

D.

Signing out on this thread.

Bastet · October 07, 2006, 10:15:24 AM

Hmm, long post, now i did read all this and i have some of my own opions which you will probebly not like. But here goes.

I dont think the thread title here we go again is in order. Vis isnt good for a hunter, where this is one of the best hunter melee weapons due to the stats. Also if said hunter has more DKP then you, under the highest dkp wins one can say its totaly fair, he has more dkp, he has more right.

Now you can say that system aint fair since its not in the best intrest in the group. Maybe, but it takes a while for everyone to adjust to the system, it took a while for RG1, and its working rather neat now.

Then again, i fail to see how these rather annoying bitchy posts about it are in the best intrest of the group. The make the hunter that bought it feel bad, and gets everyone up on the us vs them stands which its rather hard to get them of off as a Raidleader.

Lastly if youd really cared about the raid group, youd be happy for one of your fellow raids to get a darn good sword and congratulate him with it rather then comming here to **** on the raid, guild and officers for the systems that are in place.

StrontiumDog · October 07, 2006, 11:00:48 AM

I think that maybe this topic should be closed.

TeaLeaf · October 07, 2006, 12:38:54 PM

Quote from: StrontiumDog;154852I think that maybe this topic should be closed.

....last time I did that the Officers got a bollocking from people for stopping free speech. One things clear, nobody is happy all the time, but the majority move forward happy.

If you consider this thread closed then please stop posting.

TL.

Sinap · October 07, 2006, 01:18:26 PM

Quote from: shadowscream;154828not everyone raids every week, and not exactly farm status

Dont expect to get anything by being a part timer then, the idea is that raiders attend neare enough every raid to make the attendance.

Also, when was the last time you spent a night wiping on Garr and called it a night because you just couldnt do it and had to go farm more potions for dps and what not?

shadowscream · October 07, 2006, 02:07:27 PM

Quote from: Sinap;154874Dont expect to get anything by being a part timer then, the idea is that raiders attend neare enough every raid to make the attendance.

Also, when was the last time you spent a night wiping on Garr and called it a night because you just couldnt do it and had to go farm more potions for dps and what not?

hey I wasn't refering to me, I have more than 80% attencance on rg2 my point was that we don't do MC that often in rg2 since we decided to do BWL
now I'm gonna stop posting here no matter what you say :narnar:

Zabard · October 07, 2006, 02:15:01 PM

Just a few things.

I named it here we go again because last time this happened, we had a large disucssion about it. People said that we should rather let common sense rule than having a loot priority. I disagreed with this, because I see that this doesn't apply to many people. I argued that I felt we should keep it the way we had it. So, after it finally drops (it didn't drop for aprox. a month), it gets handed to a hunter. There never went out any information about we dropping loot priority, the other rogues were as surprised as me. Now this is only a single incident, but as I mentioned before, I was on the other side of the table last time this happened as well, and now being "the victim" of this one as well, in addition to learning that we no longer had priority made me quite mad, tbh. Treating people differently is something I'm no big fan of. What's more, after our lengthy discussion about using common sense and seeing that I was right and that the system of whispering of others with perhaps more use of an item not being used either made me more angry.

I also said earlier I would regret saying some of the things I said, and I do. I'm sorry this caused such a big fuzz, specially to Donnie. I feel a lot better now, specially after seeing this video.

TeaLeaf · October 07, 2006, 10:20:20 PM

Quote from: Zabard;154887Treating people differently is something I'm no big fan of.

Good, because we treat them all the same. You got DKP, you can buy it.
We do not control people or their version of CommonSense(TM) v2.1.

It's a game, it will drop again real soon and you can get it then. Move on please, because the alternative is an administrative nightmare and you'd be opening the WoW equivalent of Pandoras' box and stretching raid times into days not hours whilst we debate the 'true' version of 'priority' for each item.

TL.